The flashback was beautiful. I was invited to a Jewish temple to sell books for Maria Van Lieshout’s talk about her graphic novel “Song of a Blackbird.” As I waited, I heard children singing in Hebrew — words and melodies and the thump, thump, thumps of little hands reminded me of my childhood Hebrew school. Soon children and adults came in, and we were mesmerized by Van Lieshout sharing the stories that inspired her to create the book.
The Book: In 1943 Amsterdam, Emma Bergsma’s world changes when she witnesses Jewish families being forcibly deported to concentration camps. That pivotal moment lights a fire within her, and she decides to join the Dutch Resistance — drawn into a clandestine world of printing presses and counterfeiters, with thousands of lives on the line.
In 2011 Amsterdam, teenage Annick’s world changes — searching for a bone marrow donor for her beloved oma leads to a shocking revelation: Her grandmother was secretly adopted as a child. The only clues to finding their lost family are a series of art prints, each signed by a mysterious “Emma B.”
This novel weaves together two timelines to reveal how art — in the face of political upheaval and nearly insurmountable adversity — can become our greatest lifeline.
Van Lieshout shared stories of the people she based the book on — heroic members of the Netherlands resistance. As she talked about people being rounded up, the free press becoming purveyors of propaganda, schools losing their freedom, historic institutions dismantled, too few speaking out — my chest tightened, anger bubbling up. I wondered if others felt the same.
Hours earlier, I had donated money to send two American children to their mother’s home country. Their mother had shown up for a routine ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) appointment and was suddenly deported. Her children — U.S. citizens — had no other caregivers. The painful decision was made to send them to their mother, to a country they had never seen. I thought of them as Van Lieshout told us about Jewish children, separated from their parents at a Nazi deportation center, who — with their parents’ secret permission — were whisked away to other families through an underground railroad. Most never saw their parents again. 102,000 Dutch Jews were killed in the Holocaust. The resistance saved 600 children.
I was thinking of today’s America — people rounded up and deported, visa holders thrown into jails without due process, children separated from their parents, an American child with late-stage cancer deported, homes burst into by masked armed agents with warrants for the wrong people, mothers and children forced outside in their underwear, a student accosted outside her home, handcuffed, taken hundreds of miles away to jail, whose only “crime” was writing an op-ed. Major universities are being attacked — funding slashed, mainstream media threatened with lawsuits and lost licenses, law firms barred from entering federal courts, lists of disabled people gathered for “studies,” university professors getting federal government texts asking if they’re Jewish, government civil and human rights agencies dismantled, judges threatened with impeachment — one handcuffed and arrested outside her courtroom — the U.S. Attorney General bragging about signing death warrants. … All of that was rattling in my head.
Recommended for you
Van Lieshout ended by showing photographs of the story’s main WWII characters. Most didn’t survive, but they saved thousands of lives. After a few general questions, one person brought up parallels with today. I could see how some of us had been holding something tightly in our chests — and suddenly, it was released, free. I’ll paraphrase what one person said: During the war, horrible atrocities were committed. Millions were murdered. But during the years leading up to the war, it all could have been prevented. If only people had stood up and resisted earlier — when the seeds of hate were being planted, as the structures of democracy were dismantled — countless lives could have been saved.
It is always dangerous to compare any moment to what led to the Holocaust, but there I was — sitting in a room full of Jewish people — my skin crawling because history may not repeat, but it clearly rhymes. Just as I felt a warmth wash over my body hearing Jewish children singing in Hebrew, dread gripped me hearing Van Lieshout’s story. How many more Jewish children might there be today — singing in Hebrew schools — if 6 million of us hadn’t been slaughtered? Eighty-five million people died in WWII, countless others wounded, entire nations forever traumatized.
Will we hear the song of a blackbird now — trying to get the attention of a generation bombarded by noise — to stand up against tyranny right here at home? If not, an era of darkness may be near — from which there might be no escape.
Here are the first lines of the book:
I’m singing to you. Yes, you.
WILL YOU LISTEN?
Craig Wiesner is the co-owner of Reach And Teach, a book, toy and cultural gift shop on San Carlos Avenue in San Carlos. Follow Craig: craigwiesner.bsky.social.
Craig - as a native of the Netherlands and born during the war, I am very familiar with the plight and extermination of the Dutch Jewish population. Her book quite accurately describes what happened. I take issue with comparing the tragedies of the Jewish children with the voluntary children's deportation of illegal immigrants. The latter had a way to return to the country of their parents' origin whereas the Jewish children were sent to their extermination. Also, the mother of the deported children is responsible for their wellbeing and had made the decision to come here without legal documentation. That is in no way comparable with the status of the Jewish parents who were legal Dutch residents. Your sob story is an insult to the millions of Jewish children who were not given a choice and were killed because of their ethnicity.
Ah yes…Mr. Wiesner attempting to weave another tale that to no surprise, ends up in another column exhibiting the “D” in Trump Derangement Syndrome. Sorry, Mr. Wiesner, but since you include easily debunked fake news and lies from Democrat talking points regarding ICE, we can’t take you seriously. What you don’t seem to realize is that if we remove your fake news and lies allegations (basically, remove the “D” in TDS) your column supports what our (yes, our) great President Trump is doing to protect our country.
Perhaps what should be rattling around in your head are the protests at major universities which advocate for another Holocaust-level extinction of Jews. Or the deaths of a Washington DC couple because they were Jewish. They will no longer be able to sing. Or the targeted terrorist event yesterday against Jewish families in Colorado from a person yelling “Free Palestine.” A perpetrator who should have been deported previously but was allowed to stay due to Biden’s treasonous actions of not securing our border. We should ask all Americans, “WILL YOU LISTEN?” Apparently, President Trump and his administration are listening. And they should be thanked in their quest to Make America Great Again, Again.
Thanks, JustMike650 and Jorg, for your feedback. Perhaps one or both of you could use this as a teachable moment and rewrite my comment to express my sentiments in what you would consider a non-abusive manner. I believe, JustMike650, I proffered a similar challenge last year but there was never a response. Don’t worry. I wasn’t offended then and I won’t be offended if one or both of you are unable to meet the challenge. TY in advance.
So nothing to teach, eh JustMike650 and Jorg? Don’t worry. I’m not surprised, nor offended. Have a Trump-tastic day! BTW, I was interested in how AI would rewrite my comment and to no surprise, not much of a change. The most was about a 10% change and it was mostly because AI attempted to use “politically correct” speech and reduce my turns of phrase to expand the audience to folks who don’t understand them.
Thanks, Craig, for a column that serves as a great example of why analogy is a weak form argument. You may have said it best when you wrote, "It is always dangerous to compare any moment to what led to the Holocaust..." but that's what you have done.
An overwhelming majority of Americans want undocumented criminal elements who are exploiting our system expelled. They also disagree with Hamas supporters who are calling for the genocidal extermination of Jews. What irony... you compare folks who oppose antisemitism today with an authoritarian regime that made antisemitism the centerpiece of that regime's warped world view.
I'm beginning to think what really aggravates extreme loyalists in the Democratic Party and progressives is rejection. They have been rejected by the American people. That rejection now plays out in aggression, lack of empathy, and loss of self-control. Aggression... what else would you call the phenomenal rise in hate crimes against Jews? Are those heinous acts coming from the right or the left? Lack of empathy... what else would explain the left turning their backs to persons victimized by the left's open border policies of the previous four years. Three months ago, the left's leaders could not overcome their disdain for the president to acknowledge the enormous suffering of those victims. Loss of self-control... how else would you describe leftist legislators and jurists going beyond acceptable protests, which is their right, to physically attempt entry when they have no authority to do so or conceal persons wanted for criminality? Profanity laced commentary is even more evidence that the left's leaders have lost self-control.
We should not applaud the deterioration of the Democratic Party. Our country needs a strong two-party system. Your party IMO needs to get over the rejection and get busy rolling up its sleeves and start representing the millions of Americans who want to remain faithful to the party. Today's column is not a step in that direction.
Keep the discussion civilized. Absolutely NO
personal attacks or insults directed toward writers, nor others who
make comments. Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd,
racist or sexually-oriented language. Don't threaten. Threats of harming another
person will not be tolerated. Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone
or anything. Be proactive. Use the 'Report' link on
each comment to let us know of abusive posts. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. Anyone violating these rules will be issued a
warning. After the warning, comment privileges can be
revoked.
Please purchase a Premium Subscription to continue reading.
To continue, please log in, or sign up for a new account.
We offer one free story view per month. If you register for an account, you will get two additional story views. After those three total views, we ask that you support us with a subscription.
A subscription to our digital content is so much more than just access to our valuable content. It means you’re helping to support a local community institution that has, from its very start, supported the betterment of our society. Thank you very much!
(8) comments
Craig - as a native of the Netherlands and born during the war, I am very familiar with the plight and extermination of the Dutch Jewish population. Her book quite accurately describes what happened. I take issue with comparing the tragedies of the Jewish children with the voluntary children's deportation of illegal immigrants. The latter had a way to return to the country of their parents' origin whereas the Jewish children were sent to their extermination. Also, the mother of the deported children is responsible for their wellbeing and had made the decision to come here without legal documentation. That is in no way comparable with the status of the Jewish parents who were legal Dutch residents. Your sob story is an insult to the millions of Jewish children who were not given a choice and were killed because of their ethnicity.
Ah yes…Mr. Wiesner attempting to weave another tale that to no surprise, ends up in another column exhibiting the “D” in Trump Derangement Syndrome. Sorry, Mr. Wiesner, but since you include easily debunked fake news and lies from Democrat talking points regarding ICE, we can’t take you seriously. What you don’t seem to realize is that if we remove your fake news and lies allegations (basically, remove the “D” in TDS) your column supports what our (yes, our) great President Trump is doing to protect our country.
Perhaps what should be rattling around in your head are the protests at major universities which advocate for another Holocaust-level extinction of Jews. Or the deaths of a Washington DC couple because they were Jewish. They will no longer be able to sing. Or the targeted terrorist event yesterday against Jewish families in Colorado from a person yelling “Free Palestine.” A perpetrator who should have been deported previously but was allowed to stay due to Biden’s treasonous actions of not securing our border. We should ask all Americans, “WILL YOU LISTEN?” Apparently, President Trump and his administration are listening. And they should be thanked in their quest to Make America Great Again, Again.
Abusive post ....
As always!
Thanks, JustMike650 and Jorg, for your feedback. Perhaps one or both of you could use this as a teachable moment and rewrite my comment to express my sentiments in what you would consider a non-abusive manner. I believe, JustMike650, I proffered a similar challenge last year but there was never a response. Don’t worry. I wasn’t offended then and I won’t be offended if one or both of you are unable to meet the challenge. TY in advance.
So nothing to teach, eh JustMike650 and Jorg? Don’t worry. I’m not surprised, nor offended. Have a Trump-tastic day! BTW, I was interested in how AI would rewrite my comment and to no surprise, not much of a change. The most was about a 10% change and it was mostly because AI attempted to use “politically correct” speech and reduce my turns of phrase to expand the audience to folks who don’t understand them.
Thanks, Craig, for a column that serves as a great example of why analogy is a weak form argument. You may have said it best when you wrote, "It is always dangerous to compare any moment to what led to the Holocaust..." but that's what you have done.
An overwhelming majority of Americans want undocumented criminal elements who are exploiting our system expelled. They also disagree with Hamas supporters who are calling for the genocidal extermination of Jews. What irony... you compare folks who oppose antisemitism today with an authoritarian regime that made antisemitism the centerpiece of that regime's warped world view.
I'm beginning to think what really aggravates extreme loyalists in the Democratic Party and progressives is rejection. They have been rejected by the American people. That rejection now plays out in aggression, lack of empathy, and loss of self-control. Aggression... what else would you call the phenomenal rise in hate crimes against Jews? Are those heinous acts coming from the right or the left? Lack of empathy... what else would explain the left turning their backs to persons victimized by the left's open border policies of the previous four years. Three months ago, the left's leaders could not overcome their disdain for the president to acknowledge the enormous suffering of those victims. Loss of self-control... how else would you describe leftist legislators and jurists going beyond acceptable protests, which is their right, to physically attempt entry when they have no authority to do so or conceal persons wanted for criminality? Profanity laced commentary is even more evidence that the left's leaders have lost self-control.
We should not applaud the deterioration of the Democratic Party. Our country needs a strong two-party system. Your party IMO needs to get over the rejection and get busy rolling up its sleeves and start representing the millions of Americans who want to remain faithful to the party. Today's column is not a step in that direction.
You ask "what led up to the holocaust?" The extermination of the mentally disabled for starters.
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep the discussion civilized. Absolutely NO personal attacks or insults directed toward writers, nor others who make comments.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Anyone violating these rules will be issued a warning. After the warning, comment privileges can be revoked.