Judge finds Virginia Democrats' redistricting resolution illegal; new Maryland map advances

The latest developments are part of a national battle over unusual mid-decade redistricting attempts, launched last summer by Trump who urged Republican officials in Texas to redraw maps to help the GOP win more seats. He did so in hopes of holding on to a narrow House majority in the face of political headwinds that typically favor the party out of power in midterms.

Tazewell Circuit Court Judge Jack Hurley Jr. struck down the Virginia legislature’s actions on three grounds, including finding that lawmakers failed to follow their own rules for adding the redistricting amendment to a special session.

His order also said Democrats failed to approve the amendment before the public began voting in last year’s general election and failed to publish the amendment three months before the election, as required by law. As a result, he said, the amendment was invalid and void.

Plans for appeal

Virginia House Speaker Don Scott, who was listed in Republicans' lawsuit over the resolution, said Democrats would appeal the ruling.

“Nothing that happened today will dissuade us from continuing to move forward and put this matter directly to the voters,” Scott said in a joint statement with other Democratic leaders.

Virginians for Fair Elections, a campaign that supports the redistricting resolution, accused conservatives of filing their lawsuit in a known GOP-friendly jurisdiction, saying, “Republicans court-shopped for a ruling because litigation and misinformation are the only tools they have left.”

Hurley’s ruling came after lawmakers said they would unveil their proposed new districts to voters by the end of this week.

The state is currently represented in the House by six Democrats and five Republicans from districts whose boundaries were imposed by a court after a bipartisan redistricting commission failed to agree on a map after the 2020 census.

Because the commission was established by a voter-approved constitutional amendment, lawmakers have to revise the constitution in order to be able to redraw maps this year. That requires the pass a resolution in two separate legislative sessions, with a state election sandwiched in between.

Virginians would have to vote in favor in a referendum.

Maryland

Moore, a Democrat who is the nation's only serving Black governor, said the state needed to act to counter what he called “political redlining” by Trump in other states at the cost of Black representation in Congress.

He compared Trump’s push for GOP-friendly redistricting to discriminatory housing practices, saying the president and his allies “are doing everything in their power to silence the voices and trying to eliminate Black leadership — elected leadership — all over this country.”

“So no, I will not sit quiet,” Moore testified. “And the audacity of those who are telling me to do so shows that they have no understanding of the journey of so many who came before us.”

Democrats outnumber Republicans 2-1 in Maryland and already hold a 7-1 advantage in the state’s U.S. House delegation, with Rep. Andy Harris the lone GOP representative.

Moore's push for mid-decade redistricting has run into opposition by a key fellow Democrat: state Senate President Bill Ferguson, of Baltimore, who says it could backfire and potentially cost a Democratic seat.

Ferguson pointed out that a map adopted in 2021 that would have made it easier to flip Harris' seat was ruled unconstitutional by a judge who called it “a product of extreme partisan gerrymandering.” Maryland passed another map in 2022, and a legal fight was dropped.

Redrawing districts again could prompt a new legal challenge and lead a court to impose districts, Ferguson contends.

On Tuesday he told reporters that his position has not changed and a majority of Democratic state senators also oppose redistricting now.

“I understand that people have differences of opinion, but I don’t see that shifting here,” Ferguson said.

A Maryland House committee advanced legislation containing the map to the House, after several hours of testimony from residents.

Julie Quick, who lives on Maryland’s Eastern Shore in Harris’ district, testified that the map “takes a sledgehammer to rural voting rights.”

Ben Vaughan, who testified in favor of the map, told lawmakers “our democracy is a house on fire,” and the state needs to “turn on the fire hoses.”

Other states

At the national level, the redistricting battle has resulted so far in nine more seats that Republicans believe they can win in Texas, Missouri, North Carolina and Ohio, and six that Democrats think they can win in California and Utah. Democrats hope to fully or partially make up that three-seat margin in Virginia.

As in Virginia, redistricting is still being litigated in several states, and there is no guarantee that the parties will win the seats they have redrawn.

Republican Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis plans to call a special session on redistricting in April.

Witte reported from Annapolis, Maryland. Associated Press writer David A. Lieb in Jefferson City, Missouri, contributed. Olivia Diaz is a corps member for The Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.