Editor,
I am truly amazed at the depth of Natalie Doud’s understanding of the “participation trophy” (Student News column, “The truth behind the shiny participation trophy” in the Dec. 17 edition of the Daily Journal).
Recommended for you
Post a comment as Guest
Report
Watch this discussion. Stop watching this discussion.
Thank you for visiting the Daily Journal.
Please purchase a Premium Subscription to continue reading.
To continue, please log in, or sign up for a new account.
We offer one free story view per month. If you register for an account, you will get two additional story views. After those three total views, we ask that you support us with a subscription.
A subscription to our digital content is so much more than just access to our valuable content. It means you’re helping to support a local community institution that has, from its very start, supported the betterment of our society. Thank you very much!
Want to join the discussion?
Only subscribers can view and post comments on articles.
Already a subscriber? Login Here
Latest News
- Millbrae ‘on track’ with state housing requirements
- New AI cameras will monitor bus drivers
- Fears of a global energy crisis rise as Iran keeps stranglehold on shipping and hits Dubai airport
- Poland is now among the world's 20 largest economies. How did it happen?
- Trump suggests he may delay China trip as he pressures Beijing for help with Strait of Hormuz
- Ben McCollum sparks another turnaround as Iowa returns to the NCAA Tournament, Clemson on deck
- March Madness gives fans a celebration to relieve all the consternation in college sports
- The Latest: Trump calls for help to reopen the Strait of Hormuz
Trending Stories
Articles
- Housing for San Mateo Safeway site
- New details on potential 101/92 connector project in San Mateo
- Wrongful death lawsuit alleges city of Burlingame, driver, 11-year-old e-bike rider and parents at fault
- Student sues after alleged sexual assault by Woodside volleyball coach
- Who puts up the Highway 101 political banners?
- Vacant San Mateo lot gets approval for development
- San Francisco International Airport’s AirTrain workers on strike
- Express lane data confirms violation concerns
- Visible lack of unity
- San Mateo passes gas leaf blower ban
Images
Videos
Commented
- Just the facts (13)
- Hope for the younger generation (12)
- Student walk-outs bring hope (10)
- Feminism: let’s talk about it (9)
- Governor’s race has a dilution problem (9)
- Loneliness, suicide and the crisis facing young men (8)
- San Mateo County Board of Supervisors scopes e-bike ordinance (8)
- 'Affordable' housing? (8)
- Trump-racist (8)
- Who puts up the Highway 101 political banners? (7)
- BART revises its station closure plan — slightly (6)
- What could be worse? (6)
- Belmont leaders push for ECR bike lanes (6)
- Reasons for war misunderstood by many (6)
- An ax to grind? (6)
- 101/92 fix (6)
- Buyers beware: Not all e-bikes are e-bikes (6)
- Noncitizen voting (6)
- Iran’s supreme leader killed in major attack by US and Israel (6)
- Invading Iran is not a noble cause (6)
- Sticks and stones will break my bones ... (6)
- Difficulties with current councilmember (6)
- I’m boycotting the State of the Union — here’s why (6)
- Californians love cars (5)
- Following Trump off a cliff (5)
- 16-year-old who died in e-moto crash identified (5)
- Beyond (5)
- Wrongful death lawsuit alleges city of Burlingame, driver, 11-year-old e-bike rider and parents at fault (5)
- Editorial: Horizon treatment center in the right location (5)
- San Mateo county representatives support war powers resolution (5)
- SAVE Act won’t save anyone (5)
- The cosmic calculator (5)
- Protecting families from the ‘property tax overload’ (4)
- Journalism: Can just about anyone do it? (4)
- The truth about Iran (4)
- Express lane data confirms violation concerns (4)
- The promise of America (4)
- Keep supporting Ukraine (4)
- Demolition meets democracy (4)
- In solidarity with students (4)
- Opposition to treatment center unwarranted (4)
- Your Berlin moment? (4)
- High gas prices (3)
- California has 40,000 affordable housing units ready to break ground. One setback is holding them up (3)
- Getting work done: Why humility still wins (3)
- Suspect in hit-and-run of juvenile bicyclist arrested in Foster City (3)
- Freedom and justice? (3)
- Worthy women to be honored this Friday (3)
- Mobile vending in Redwood City (3)
- Corruption in state government (3)
- Flurry of new developments for San Mateo (3)
- The end of the good life in San Mateo (3)
- Sound familiar? (3)
- San Mateo pushes electric again (3)
- Consider Trump’s actions (3)
- Oh boy (3)
- Colma BART depot opened 30 years ago (3)
- International Women’s Day: Who gets to build the future? (3)
- House rich, cash poor (3)
- Bus and bike lanes can coexist (2)
- San Mateo OKs funds to study ECR upgrades (2)
- Bay Area disconnect (2)
- New developments in San Mateo (2)
- San Mateo passes gas leaf blower ban (2)
- What could be worse? (2)
- Gold’s historic run and why you should care (2)
- Restoring our forests (2)
- California school systems face red ink despite boosts in education spending (2)
- Support the polluters to pay Climate Superfund Act (2)
- Unhung heroes part 1 (2)
- Join us for No Kings 3 (2)
- Early stage of express lane project extended (2)
- Parcel tax could raise $12.2M for schools (2)
- God help Ukraine (2)
- No to BART tax (2)
- Ensuring a responsible transition to an AI-humancentric economy (2)
- No clear front-runner for governor, but new poll names 5 with the best shot (2)
- Leaving California (2)
- Visible lack of unity (2)
- Beyond Epstein: human trafficking awareness (2)
- San Mateo County focusing on help for homeless (2)
- San Mateo treatment center hits opposition (2)
- Housing for San Mateo Safeway site (2)
- College protesters demand end to war on Iran (2)
- BART needs strict oversight now (2)
- Hillsdale redevelopment dooms SMUHSD to deficits (2)
- Redwood City’s budget weaker than projected (2)
- Montessori school duo starts initiative helping stray cats (2)
- My $40 lesson in sustainability (1)
- Roster for San Mateo County’s June ballot closed (1)
- Wave of California teacher strikes 'is no coincidence' (1)
- Newsom is on the job (1)
- Burlingame councilmember should focus on Burlingame (1)
- More than 30,000 Kaiser Permanente health care workers to end strike in California and Hawaii (1)
- Fun for the family (1)
- Mullin’s political tantrum (1)
- Students advocating for lenient cellphone policy in San Mateo Union High School District (1)
- Virginia has a data center boon. Officials debate whether it's time to scrap its tax breaks (1)
- Get Congress on board (1)
- Notes, quotes and dust motes (1)
Latest e-Edition
- To view our latest e-Edition click the image on the left.
(3) comments
Dr. Merrill
I agree. Young folks will be shocked when they fail later in life and learn the real world is a lot different than the artificial world that rewards all with participation trophies.
Thomas Sowell... better known for his commentary on economics and politics, once said, "Equality of rights does not mean equality of results. I can have all the equal treatment in the world on a golf course and I will not finish within shouting distance of Tiger Woods."
I agree - our 3 children, now in their forties, left shelves full of trophies in our house. They even acknowledged then that they were meaningless and never looked at them again and refused to take them when they moved to their own homes. Our grandchildren are now coming home with similar atrocious looking trophies that are now twice as large.
Well written, Dr. Merrill. Unfortunately, we may need to reinstate participation trophies for women’s sports because thanks to Biden’s executive order allowing biological men to compete in women’s sports, actual biological women may not win many, if any, championship trophies in the future.
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep the discussion civilized. Absolutely NO personal attacks or insults directed toward writers, nor others who make comments.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Anyone violating these rules will be issued a warning. After the warning, comment privileges can be revoked.