I hadn’t read John Steinbeck’s “Grapes of Wrath” for 50 years, until now. In it, the Joad family is forced to leave Oklahoma with hundreds of thousands of others during “The Dust Bowl” of the 1930s.
Drought, high winds, soil erosion and poor agricultural practices killed their ability to eke out a barely sustainable lifestyle as small farmers.
Knowing this, California’s mega-wealthy farmers falsely promoted there were jobs to be had picking their crops. Good wages, plentiful food, lots of jobs, they promised. But the realities were different. There were too many people, not enough jobs, and the desperation apparent among the hungry and poor “Okies,” using the newly minted pejorative, left them struggling to find a way to stay alive.
If they didn’t like the extremely low pay, they were told others would be willing to accept it. There were thousands of others who did; their starving families gave them no other choice. If they caused trouble, the local sheriffs would run them out of town, or put them in jail. And if Filipinos, Chinese, Mexican or Japanese migrant workers said anything to displease the landowners, they were deported. But the migrant laborers never organized a cohesive movement against the tyrants.
There are too many parallels to 2025 to ignore.
From FDR’s New Deal, which provided a way out of the Great Depression of the 1930s, through the end of Barack Obama’s second term, along with numerous social changes like civil and voting rights, the American people, including those who moved here from countries outside of the United States as did my own ancestors fleeing persecution and violence, did so with the intention of pursuing the economic and educational opportunities this country offered. The United States was an imperfect, yet imperative idea that became synonymous with freedom, acceptance, tolerance, experimentation and hard work. Despite its flaws, it remained a place to be admired.
Something was brewing in the 1990s, however. It was mostly overlooked, but the Christian right was slowly and insidiously working its way onto school boards, local town councils, county boards and other local and state spheres of influence. Democracy persisted, but began to teeter.
Recommended for you
While the Democratic Party continued to fool itself into believing that it had the minority vote, and there was no need to listen to white, rural, people, the Republicans presented a charlatan in the name of Donald Trump to offer his populist message, including derogatory references to appeal to white disenfranchisement, giving them a voice to vent their frustration. Now, in his second term, he’s openly flouting constitutional norms, laws, judge’s rulings and decency. His current budget bill, which cuts billions from health care and assistance programs, and cuts taxes for the wealthy, will result in a huge deficit and provides an overblown budget for defense and homeland security. Instead of the exploitive farmers and corporations of the 1930s depicted in Steinbeck’s book, we have this president’s mega-wealthy friends and donors upending an entire country’s equilibrium in the same brutal manner of exploitation and greed.
Let’s substitute “Okies” for immigrants, or transgender people, or Muslims, or media, or vaccines, or science research, or climate science, or universities, or law firms, or federal workers, or government agencies, or foreign allies or those who disagree with him. Trump’s desire is to be king was in full view as he comfortably mingled with the monarchs of the Middle East on his recent trip, underscored by nearly 160 executive orders.
Though resilience and courage was shown by many in the “Grapes of Wrath,” the farmers and corporations mostly prevailed. During this time of open intimidation and ignoring the rule of law by the current regime, the American people need to stand together. Autocracies that have succeeded like Duterte, Mugabe and Bolsonaro have done so without the peoples’ voices rising. Netanyahu’s attempt at overtaking the court system prior to the war in Gaza was suppressed by nationwide protests.
Can Americans rise up as one voice to beat authoritarianism?
Yes. It starts by joining one of the national groups with a local presence like Indivisible, MoveOn and many others that are peacefully resisting. In fact, June 14, the day Trump is to use the 250th anniversary of the Army as a parade to celebrate his birthday is the next step. “No Kings Day” features nationwide pro-democracy demonstrations, not against the military, but against the antidemocratic regime of this administration. This is about showing that WE THE PEOPLE don’t want authoritarians to rule, but democracy to reign.
Jordan Steven Sher is author of three books about the 1990s war in Bosnia, and his most recent, Dark Shadows Hover, about the Holocaust in the former Yugoslavia. He lives in San Carlos.
(7) comments
Hello, Jordan
I’ll begin this post with, “It has been a long, long time since we last spoke. Looks like things are going well for you... I'm glad.” I used those same words in the thread following your LTE dated Jan. 25, 2021 titled, “Where to from here?” In that letter, you criticized Trump supporters who insisted the 2020 election had been stolen. I responded to you with what I said twelve weeks before your LTE appeared in print… Joe won. I agreed with you that we should move past what did or did not happen in November 2020 and put our focus on other issues… like immigration. I also addressed your LTE’s left wing talking point about systemic racism. We’ll come back to that.
Today’s guest perspective is filled with progressive talking points. In it, you compare Big Ag luring Okie farm workers to California with immigrants who crossed our border during the past four years. It’s a false equivalency. Big Ag beckoned migrants in the 1930s for selfish financial gain, but Joe Biden beckoned nearly 90 years later for selfish political gain. We are now paying the price for the Democratic Party’s failed leadership over the past four years.
Some DJ readers on the left side of the aisle may chafe at comments laying the blame for the violence this week in LA on Democratic Party leadership, but I don’t recall Okies storming LA’s City Hall to demand better wages and other benefits.
You called for “peaceful resistance” to current administration policy, and I agree with you again. Let’s have it… lots of it. However, what we cannot have is rioters assaulting police officers and setting fires in downtown LA. When we saw violence across American cities in the summer of 2020, where was the Democratic Party’s leadership? In your 2021 LTE, you also wrote, “Of course, any violence is abhorrent, but Black lives have not mattered for 400 years, and the visible injustices of murdered black people is deeply rooted in the racism that befouls this nation.”
Those murders are also rooted in the Democratic Party’s failed leadership. The year before you wrote those words about “deeply rooted” racism, 575 Blacks (mostly young men) were shot and killed in Chicago. Where was the Democratic leadership? Chicago had the No. 10 murder rate in the country, and the Democratic Party also controlled the other nine cities. We sure heard a lot of rhetoric from the left about systematic racism during the past four years. Where was the left’s outrage over the senseless slaughter of Blacks in cities controlled by the Democratic Party for decades? Where were the protests?
Coming full circle to “The Grapes of Wrath,” both sides of my family… Okies and Arkies… migrated to Kern County in the 1930s. I know all about their suffering, and I know we need migrants in our country… desperately. However, neither party has moved the needle on real immigration reform. That’s beyond sad. We are now seeing in LA and other American cities more consequences of the Democratic Party’s failed leadership. Those consequences following four years of failed leadership at the border cannot be laid at the feet of the current administration.
You’re correct when you write, “WE THE PEOPLE don’t want authoritarians to rule…” Neither do the people want the progressive agenda that features overregulation controlling our everyday lives, dependency on government hand-outs obtained by picking the pockets of working Americans, and censorship to squelch points of view not aligned with the progressives’ agenda. Controlling people’s lives, creating dependency, and silencing dissent is not the way to promote democracy.
Mr. Sher conveniently forgets that President Trump was democratically elected and is implementing his campaign promises. Mr. Sher clearly likes democracy only when his agenda is pursued but that is not what the majority had in mind. The tiresome comparison of the dust bowl victims with others coming over the border is another cheap shot that only stirs sentimental but irrelevant discourse. So far Mr. Trump appears to have the support of most Americans much to the chagrin of the elites who would rather see our country burn and run by lunatics waiving foreign flags. Well, knock yourself out on King Day and wallow in your self delusion.
Yawn, snore…here we go again with a 750-word attempt to weave an apples-to-oranges tale to pen another “orange man bad” diatribe. Hey Mr. Sher, perhaps you don’t recognize the irony, but what you’re calling “No Kings Day” can alternatively be interpreted as a celebration of Flag Day and better yet, our (yes, our) great President Trump’s birthday. So essentially, everyone is celebrating Trump’s birthday. If these celebrations go off without a hitch – congrats to everyone in celebrating Trump’s birthday. But, if these celebrations include violence or untoward activity, local so-called leaders will take the heat and we can see whether local law enforcement was allowed to do their job and keep law and order. If not, I’ll notify the feds that the National Guard may need to be sent to our little town. Another plus. If any shenanigans occur, it’ll only harden the opposition to the opposition of President Trump and his common sense America First policies.
Personally, I’d like to see law enforcement launch their drones and and parade their military surplus vehicles to a staging area perimeter. Just in case protesters and paid agitators need to be kettled due to rowdiness. I’d also recommend folks take as much video/photos as possible in the event things get out of control. It’ll help the feds find/prosecute troublemakers. And finally, you may want to park away from the parade route, if there is one, just in case folks decide to recreate Los Angeles and set fire to cars or hop on top of cars to wave a Mexican or other nation’s flag.
https://apnews.com/video/padilla-says-he-was-removed-from-news-conference-for-demanding-answers-about-immigration-enforcement-c4b93bcfdf7142a8b4d85fbbde57b041
https://apnews.com/article/alex-padilla-noem-immigration-protest-california-f67d220a0254473c53c16aa96f554239
Readers will come to their own conclusions. We already know how some will respond…
So now, DavidKristofferson, you’ve given up providing commentary and you think promoting selectively edited and biased links means something? I’m not sure why you’re giving me links to Mr. Padilla’s failed performative politics episode but since you did, allow me to provide a link from a CNN security analyst (https://www.foxnews.com/media/cnn-security-analyst-defends-kristi-noem-agents-who-restrained-sen-padilla) which provides commentary on Mr. Padilla’s political “look at me, look at me, don’t look at Newsom or Bass” stunt. Unfortunately for Mr. Padilla, this embarrassing episode will haunt him for the rest of his career. Much like your commentary, these links won't sway any opinions. Have a Trump-tastic day!
https://www.c-span.org/clip/news-conference/senator-padilla-forcibly-removed-from-dhs-secretary-noem-news-conference-in-la/5165432
https://www.c-span.org/program/news-conference/senator-padilla-holds-news-conference/661198
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep the discussion civilized. Absolutely NO personal attacks or insults directed toward writers, nor others who make comments.
Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Anyone violating these rules will be issued a warning. After the warning, comment privileges can be revoked.