Matt Grocott

Matt Grocott 

How many of us caught Trump’s State of the Union Address? I did not, not at least the live broadcast. Like many, my schedule was too busy. I was coaching a junior high wrestling team. However, after seeing so much commentary on the internet, both positive and negative, I knew I had to watch it. Easily, I found his speech online and gave it the 82 minutes required to watch, from start to finish.

The time was worthwhile. It was an important speech, if for no other reason than to hear the president lay out the meaning of his phrase, “Make America Great Again.”

The president cited numerous examples of great Americans from our past. One was Buzz Aldrin, the Apollo 11 astronaut who, along with Neil Armstrong, set foot on the moon in 1969. Mr. Aldrin was in the audience and was given a standing ovation. On July 21 of this year will be the 50th anniversary of that historical event.

It is fitting and important to give recognition to great Americans like Mr. Aldrin, especially before those of his generation are passed. The president adroitly used the opportunity to point to our future. He spoke of continued space exploration and he stated emphatically, “this year, American astronauts will go back to space on American rockets.”

The president went on to highlight many past achievements of our country and to cite the many great things America is yet to do and can do in her future. He intoned, however, these accomplishments can only be achieved by “rejecting the politics of revenge, resistance and retribution, and embrace the boundless potential of cooperation, compromise and the common good.”

After these words, there was a standing ovation by most of the audience … but not all. Auspiciously, there were those dressed in white who did not stand, did not applaud, but instead sat stone faced. “Why,” I wondered about the white outfits? And specifically, “Why white?” Throughout the rest of the president’s speech, I took note of these audience members. The question came to mind: “When in America’s past has such a strong display of disunity been witnessed?” And I wondered, is what some are characterizing as a “cold civil war” upon us?

Many examples can be given of when the white-clad audience members sat idle. For instance, when the president said: “Tonight, I ask you to choose greatness,” they sat idle. He spoke about our economy, our net export of energy, the number of Americans who are off unemployment and working, lowered taxes and the doubling of the “child tax credit.” Idle. He cited a new and significant legislation called, “Right to Try.” No applause. He spoke of our military strength and then ended this segment of his speech with the statement, “Members of Congress, the state of our union is strong!” No applause from these few.

One must wonder, if these people cannot applaud the good things happening in America today, what is it they would applaud? A weak economy? More Americans unemployed and receiving government aid? Would they rather see Americans sitting in lines waiting to buy gasoline for $7.99 a gallon? Or paying $5 per therm for natural gas and $1.25 per kilowatt for electricity? Maybe they would prefer the “child tax credit” did not exist? Perhaps they would rather our military be weak, to have our Navy in ships from World War II and our Air Force flying planes from the Vietnam era?

While these examples are significant, what struck me most was when the president called for legislation to “prohibit the late term abortion of children who can feel pain in the mother’s womb.” Not only did these people not applaud, the look on their faces was stone cold.

For me, this is an extremely personal issue. Once, while having a discussion with my mother as an adult, she shared with me that were abortion legal at the time she carried me, she would have considered the option. I do not hold this against my mother. What she stated was matter of fact. However, I do take it personally that in America today, knowing what we know medically about a child in the womb, we still do not offer that child the protection of life. It is a moral travesty.

Earlier I posed the question, not authored by me, but which I have heard others ask: Are we in the midst of a cold civil war? If we are, is an underlying issue, much as slavery was in the 1860s, that of abortion? I invite your thoughts on the question.

A former member of the San Carlos City Council and mayor, Matt Grocott has been involved in political policy on the Peninsula for 17 years. He can be reached by email at mattgrocott@comcast.net.

Recommended for you

(9) comments

SB

Mr. Grocott needs to remember, "Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak and to remove all doubt", I'm guessing he never watched any of Oboma's speeches or payed attention to the lack of respect from the Republicans in attendance. How embarrasing that a former politician doesn't recognize the symbolims of the suffragete movement, but not surprised considering he seems to lack respect for women.

Christopher Conway

Hey SB, do you ever feel bad about saying someone has a lack of respect for women without having any proof of such a salacious accusation. Or does that just a reflex of anyone you don't agree with.

Dirk van Ulden

The talking points from the left never end. Could the last two responders please, please come up with some original drivel?? The women in white reminded me of the drones that attend communist party congresses and wait for their Dear Leader Pelosi to tell them whether to applause or stay seated. Isn't there at least one Democrat who disagrees or are those 'fresh faces' part of the pending disastrous cultural revolution? All we need to see next is the equivalent of Mao's Red Books.

Hikertom

For me, the worst thing about Trump is how frequently and casually he lies. I get the impression that he doesn't believe there is such a thing as truth. He thinks reality is whatever he says it is. A good example was his claim that a border barrier caused the violent crime rate to drop in El Paso. Even after FBI statistics and El Paso law enforcement data proved that the crime rate dropped before the fence was built Trump continues to repeat that lie. As for late term abortions, it is a rare procedure that is performed when there are complications that endanger the health or life of the mother.

Karen W

Yes I did listen to the whole speech live. It was best described as "cookies and dog poop" and aptly so. This sorry excuse of a President made boast after boast of misleading "accomplishments", told lie after easily provable lie, threatened the nation to stop investigating the long list of criminal and nefarious activities by him and those closest to him, never mentioned the price tag of imprisoning so many seeking asylum, dangers of deliberate voter suppression, nor did he apologize for shutting down the government despite an agreement already approved by both Houses. He then pivoted to flag waving past accomplishments of veterans and Buzz Aldrin, made empty promises about infrastructure (which was completely ignored while GOP had majority for 2 years), AIDS eradication and childhood cancer. All BS cookies. Yet you, Mr. Grocott, don't understand why fresh young energetic faces in Congress, many wearing white, didn't choose to play along with his charade. If Trump cares so much about the heartbreak of childhood cancer, then tell me why his biggest accomplishments thus far have been to poison our water and air? And that's just one example of how this con man speaks pretty when he can read a TelePrompTer yet never follows through with even the sanctions on Russia demanded by Senate and Congress?

Terence Y

Karen W - sounds like you have a major case of TDS. You're not going to be very happy for the next 6 years. Maybe you should do as President Trump tweeted, "The Democrats are so self righteous and ANGRY! Loosen up and have some fun. The Country is doing well!"

JME

Yep, let's have a wall building holiday, Everyone chip in , Free burgers for all.

Christopher Conway

We are definitely in a civil war, but I would not call it a cold one. I would call it red hot.

JME

"Are you there Ulysses? Sounds like more Confederate chatter again.
Making for another rumble.?" Abe

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.