PDA

View Full Version : People Who Reported Dr. Ayres: Sad, Sad, Missed Opportunities


Taylor
09-30-2008, 03:36 PM
Here is a list of people we know who complained about Dr. Ayres. Very incomplete.

1) In the mid-1970s, Dr. Hugh Ridlehuber, a partner of Ayres, inherited a patient from Ayres, a dentist's son. The father told Ridlehuber that the boy refused to go back to Ayres because of the physicals he was getting. Ridlehuber asked Ayres why he was giving the boy physicals. Ayres told him he was trained to do so at Judge Baker in Boston in the 1960s. Howeve,r a number of his colleagues at Judge Baker insist that this was not so, and indeed Judge Baker had its own pediatric unit, where the children were giving physical exams.


2) June 1987. Therapist Jeff Lugerner files a formal complaint with San Mateo Childrens Services on behalf of Ayres victim Greg Hogue. Lugerner told the Chronicle that Childrens Services covered it up because he was their primary vendor. He suspected that others had complained to Childrens Services about Ayres. He said no one contacted him again and when he tried to call, he was told that the case was closed.

3) 1987 - Dr. David Schwartz told San Mateo police officer Rick Neilsen that he believed that he had a patient, a Hispanic boy from a group home, who had been molested by Ayres. He told Neilsen that under no circumstances should a child psychiatrist be giving physicals to kids because it was dangerous. Neilsen who was investigating Ayres as part of the Greg Hogue case, deemed the case "unfounded."

4) In the 1980s, a concerned father of a victim asked pediatrician Sam Leavitt, who had referred his sons to Dr. Ayres, whether it was normal for Dr. Ayres to be making his sons strip and showing them "anatomical drawings." Dr.Leavitt, a staunch, opera-going pal of Ayres, didn't want to discuss the matter with the father and just changed the subject.

5) 1994- A victim went to the California Medical Board to say that Ayres molested him in 1966. Because the victim is out of statute, the Board does nothing. They don't even alert the police.

6)1994- A man in Folsom Prison for bank robbery confesses to a nurse during a psychiatric evaluation that Ayres molested him during court ordered sessions. When the police tried to investigate, the victim became too distraught to talk about it.

7)1997- Ten years before Ayres was arrested, a mother of a victim called Ayres' partners to complain that Ayres was touching her son. His partners held an emergency lunch and confronted Ayres. Ayres gave him the old song and dance about how he was trained at Judge Baker to give physicals in the therapeutic sessions. But all physicals of children at Judge Baker were done by their own very good pediatrics department !!! Gee, how is Dr. Ayres gonna explain this ? And how is he going to explain that he spoke quite differently in his deposition when he told lawyers that it was "highly unusual" for him to ever ask a child to take his pants down and that years went by when he never asked a boy to take his pants down ? In fact, he says that he has never asked a boy to take his pants down.. So why is he telling his partners that he gives physicals to boys ? The mind boggles...

Shame on his partners for not challenging their "esteemed" colleague. It is possible that they were either intimidated by Ayres and duped by his arrogance. Or, more realistically, they just didn't want to see the truth and didn't want to be bothered.

8)After Ayres was arrested, a reporter from the Bay Area
learned that another boy who had been molested in a group home around 1997, was then sent to Ayres, who tragically, molested the poor boy
again !!! The mother confronted Ayres who apologized and said it wouldn't happen again. So there we have it: Dr. Ayres admitted he was doing something wrong.

9) When a man filed the civil molestation suit in 2003, a psychiatrist
named Dr. Albert Rainieri told the victim's mother that he was "not surprised
to hear" that Ayres had molested the victim because he had been hearing stories about Ayres and boys for years. Ranieiri committed suicide in 2005.

10) A therapist revealed to a source recently that he had heard stories about Ayres and boys from another doctor "years before he was arrested."

11) A female therapist recently revealed to a source that she had a boy who was a juvenile offender who was getting strange physicals from Ayres. Alarmed, she and another therapist went to Childrens Services to file a complaint. Childrens Services thwarted them, saying there was nothing they could do because Ayres was a medical doctor and giving physicals were within his rights. Shame on you, Childrens Services.

12)Some months before Dr. Ayres was arrested, the mother of a victim told his crony and blind loyalist Dr. Etta Bryant that Ayres had molested her son. We are still waiting for Bryant to come forward to the police.

13) In the summer of 2007, after the arrest of Ayres, a group of juvenile defenders serving on the San Mateo Citizens Review Panel learned that a large number of doctors knew what Ayres was doing to boys but instead of reporting him, as they were mandated to by law, they just stopped referring boys to him.

Do we smell a plea bargain ?

Feel free to add to this list.

Wilson
10-01-2008, 06:00 AM
Psychiatrist Dr. Dick Shadoan is in the same category with Ayres cronies Dr. Etta Bryant and Dr. Sam Leavitt. We hear that he is angry at the psychiatrists who believe the victims of Dr. Ayres.

It was Dr. Shadoan who tried to get Dr. Ayres elected President of the American Psychiatric Association. We are thankful that the esteemed members of this association elected Dr. Rodrigo Munoz instead, in a landslide victory in which Munoz took 49 out of the 50 states. At least there are some good and savvy psychiatrists out there !

Michael Stogner
10-02-2008, 09:19 AM
The County of San Mateo has a paramount interest in protecting the integrity of its governmental institutions, and to ensure the County government serves the best interest of the citizens of San Mateo County.

Government Code 25303 provides that the Board of Supervisors shall supervise the official conduct of all county officers, including elected officials, and additionally provides that the Board shall see that officers faithfully perform their duties.

St. Clair Baxter
10-02-2008, 09:29 AM
-Juvenile defender Kathryn Yolken in Oakland Tribune story, 2005, "County Lawyers Defend Accused Doctor"

Quote : "I will continue to use him. I don't believe he did anything wrong. He's a fabulous psychiatrist and a great person," said Kathryn Yolken, a juvenile attorney and former county prosecutor who has worked with Ayres since 1989.

Yolken, who has prosecuted and defended child molestation cases, said she does not believe the allegations against Ayres. "I've done a lot of sexual assault and molestation cases, and it doesn't ring true," she said.

___

Last year, when a victim of Dr. Ayres called Yolken to tell her he had been victimized, Yolken did not return the victim's call. How's that for compassion ?

-Then there's Gerry Hilliard, head of juvenile defenders who not once but twice defended his pal Ayres in the press, even going so far as to say that he didn't believe the allegations and that he would send his "own grandchildren to him."

- Then we have the honorable juvenile Judge Marta Diaz, who has been known to have Dr. Ayres and Solveig over for dinner, and who according to Bay Area reporters, went around the courthouse telling everyone within earshot that the San Mateo PD better be "real careful" investigating Ayres, because she was his pal.

- How tragic and sad that the above are getting paid to protect juveniles in San Mateo County. Have we heard a peep out of Yolken, Hilliard or Diaz since Dr. Ayres was busted ? They seemed so eager to talk to the press to defend their old pal Dr. Ayres, so what's the holdup now ? Has Diaz expressed any outrage that Childrens Services and the court system failed to protect juveniles from Ayres ? Has she expressed regret for making sure Ayres got a nice fat contract with the courts not all that long ago ? We know of other juvenile judges who have expressed their regrets about this contract, but not Diaz. The silence is deafening.

One wonders about the ability of the above people to judge character.

One would also hope that Diaz, Hilliard and all those in Childrens Services who allowed this to go on for so long would be doing not just some soul searching but demanding that there be an overhaul to the way psychiatrists are hired for the courts. There needs to be a MASSIVE overhaul.

Taylor
10-02-2008, 11:55 AM
about County counsel Thomas Casey and the Dr. Ayres case:

Thomas Casey III recent statements....Dr. William Ayres case
San Mateo County Counsel.

County Counsel Tom Casey said "departments often don't know what the police and District Attorney's Office do."

What about when they do know?

Casey said the county had nothing to do with the contract with Ayres.
__

Casey disavows any knowledgment of the court contract with Dr. Ayres, but what about all of those complaints about Dr. Ayres to Childrens Services after Greg Hogue came forward ? It is our understanding that complaints about Ayres and boys were made to Childrens Services as recently as the mid-1990s. Wouldn't you think that someone at Childrens Services would start taking note of the history of complaints about Dr. Ayres ? Were they even awake ?
Does anyone keep records over there ?

Wilson
10-02-2008, 12:22 PM
On Dec. 26, 2002, San Mateo County's presiding juvenile judge, Marta Diaz, got a brutal reminder of that. A baby she had authorized to visit his home had been declared brain-dead. His father was accused of violently shaking him on Christmas Day.

A distraught Diaz wanted to know how the system failed 8-month-old Angelo Marinda and how to prevent it from ever happening again. She ordered extraordinary open hearings in the case, where she discovered critical facts she was not told before she ruled Angelo should be permitted to visit home. Diaz never heard, for instance, that Angelo and his sister had been bruised and scratched during previous unsupervised visits with their parents. Nor did Diaz know that Angelo's attorney had not talked to his temporary caregivers, who knew of previous harm to the children.

In her final report, Diaz concluded that the system had broken down, and not just in this case. Too many lawyers fail to meet personally with their clients; rather, they simply "submit" to the findings of the social workers in court, without adding information or correcting the record.

"An agency is not going to stay great without strong advocates challenging them, because that leads to complacency," Diaz said. "The 'submit culture' should have bothered me more. It ultimately poses a threat to the health and safety of children."

Michael Stogner
10-02-2008, 04:19 PM
about County counsel Thomas Casey and the Dr. Ayres case:

Thomas Casey III recent statements....Dr. William Ayres case
San Mateo County Counsel.

County Counsel Tom Casey said "departments often don't know what the police and District Attorney's Office do."

What about when they do know?

Casey said the county had nothing to do with the contract with Ayres.
__

Casey disavows any knowledgment of the court contract with Dr. Ayres, but what about all of those complaints about Dr. Ayres to Childrens Services after Greg Hogue came forward ? It is our understanding that complaints about Ayres and boys were made to Childrens Services as recently as the mid-1990s. Wouldn't you think that someone at Childrens Services would start taking note of the history of complaints about Dr. Ayres ? Were they even awake ?
Does anyone keep records over there ?

Taylor,

For many years Thomas Casey III gave legal advice to the Board of Supervisors that was not accurate. He told the BOS that they had no authority over elected officials.

The current San Mateo County Counsel Michael P. Murphy has recently provided the BOS with different legal advice.

Government Code 25303 provides that the Board of Supervisors shall supervise the official conduct of all county officers, including elected officials, and additionally provides that the Board shall see that officers faithfully perform their duties.

How long has GC25303 been on the books, was it there when Thomas Casey III was legal counsel and if so why didn't he tell the BOS about it?

I think the BOS has always had this authority and responsibility to the residents of San Mateo County.

Wilson
10-11-2008, 06:24 PM
the mandated reporters who did not report Ayres and also on the strange support of Dr. Mel Levine, another doctor accused of molesting boys, from several other doctors.

"Stop Supporting Child Molesters", written by one of Dr. Ayres' victims, is a thoughtul and well-argued piece. Everyone in Childrens Services and the San Mateo therapeutic community should read this. Parents, as well.

www.williamayreswatch.blogspot.com

Wilson
10-13-2008, 07:14 AM
was another one who heard what Ayres was up to. His name comes up repeatedly among those in thereapeutic circles. Dr. Fricke, we are still waiting for you to come forward to say what you know.

Has anyone notified the California Medical Board about the mandated reporters who failed to report Dr. Ayres ?

Wilson
07-11-2009, 11:47 AM
that Ayres was reported to Childrens Services in 1994. Yet there is no record of it.

That makes at least three complaints about Ayres to them - that we know of. That means there are most likely many more.

Michael Stogner
07-11-2009, 01:31 PM
that Ayres was reported to Childrens Services in 1994. Yet there is no record of it.

That makes at least three complaints about Ayres to them - that we know of. That means there are most likely many more.

Wilson,
The three CPS reports you are talking about have surfaced only because of lawsuits. The defense attorney Doron Weinberg produced one in this case, not the District Attorney's Office. They do not exist in the Data base that the San Mateo Police Department used in this case, according to Detective Rick Decker. It was also pointed out that the San Mateo County Sheriff's Department has authority over Hillcrest Juvenile Hall not SMPD.

The question would be how many CPS reports involving Dr. William Ayres were made since he was employed by San Mateo County in 1963?

Thats 42 years his was referred boys from Hillcrest. NO CPS REPORTS?

Not likely.

Welcome to San Mateo County

Wilson
01-08-2010, 12:30 PM
Not long ago I met a former police officer from Santa Clara County who said county agencies in Santa Clara had received a number of complaints about Ayres touching boys as well. This was back in the 1980s and 1990s.