1:10 pm

  Local News
  State / National / World
  Opinion / Letters
  Arts / Entertainment
  Submit Event
  Comics / Games
  DJ Designers
  Advertise With Us
  About Us
OP-ED: NCAA game changer
June 14, 2014, 05:00 AM Contra Costa Times

At long last, the business model — and it is a business — of America’s major college football and basketball programs is being challenged. Make no mistake, the outcome of a lawsuit in an Oakland federal courtroom could rock the world of collegiate athletics.

U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilkin is presiding over an antitrust action brought by former players alleging the National Collegiate Athletic Association conspired with business partners to profit from use of the players’ likenesses without their consent.

While a ruling expected in late summer ultimately could radically change college athletics, it will not do so immediately because NCAA President Mark A. Emmert has vowed to fight all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Wilkin has already ruled that this particular suit is only about Division I college football and basketball programs, but a decision in the plaintiffs’ favor would certainly affect all collegiate sports.

The suit has been brought by former UCLA star basketball player Ed O’Bannon and others and since joined by such basketball royalty as Oscar Robertson and Bill Russell.

O’Bannon’s argument is that the NCAA cannot prohibit college players from sharing in the proceeds from broadcasts and video games in which they or their likenesses are featured. That would essentially mean that college players could get paid for playing their sport, which the NCCA currently prohibits.

The NCAA will counter that compromising the amateur status of college sports will jeopardize the future of intercollegiate athletics. They will also argue that current rules help ensure competitive balance among the collegiate programs.

But those arguments ignore that many college programs — especially Division I football and basketball — have already become a cesspool for illicit compensation.

The suit began nearly five years ago and at the time included EA Sports, which makes video games, and the Collegiate Licensing Co., which handles the licensing rights for many of the nation’s universities. The game company and the licensing firm agreed to a $40 million settlement with the plaintiffs and were removed from the suit. But the action against the NCAA remains.

But the NCAA seemed to weaken its own arguments in this case by agreeing to a $20 million settlement in another case involving former players and similar issues. That suit, which was scheduled for trial next March, was brought by former San Ramon Valley High School star quarterback Sam Keller, who played college football at both Arizona State and Nebraska.

Our heart is with the players on this, but we realize that an unequivocal ruling in their favor would create chaos in college sports. Our fondest hope is for a settlement that establishes reasonable rules for sharing the wealth that the players help generate.



Tags: college, players, basketball, which, collegiate, sports,

Other stories from today:


Print this Page Print this Page  |  Bookmark and Share
<< Back
Return To Archives

Daily Journal Quick Poll
What do you think of the new net neutrality rules imposed by the FCC on broadband providers?

Agree, Internet access should be governed like a utility
Don't agree, it will limit the free market
Worry about taxes
Worry it will prevent further access
It's too complicated


San Mateo County resident with measles may have exposed Berkeley restaurant diners
Patrons of La Mediterranee restaurant in Berkeley may have been exposed to measles last Friday eveni..
Leonard Nimoy, famous as Mr. Spock, dies at 83
LOS ANGELES — Leonard Nimoy, the actor known and loved by generations of "Star Trek" fans as the p..
House clears way for short-term Homeland Security bill
WASHINGTON — Congress closed in Friday on approving a short-term funding bill for the Homeland Sec..
8 shot to death, including gunman, in Missouri rampage
TYRONE, Mo. — A gunman killed seven people and wounded an eighth person in an overnight house-to-h..
More >>  
©2015 San Mateo Daily Journal
San Carlos news